Syphilis
Syphilis presents us with a new disease, or what was believed to be a new disease when it first appeared in Muslim societies, beginning in the late fifteenth century. Syphilis and other European diseases were introduced into the Middle East in the early modem period by Europeans, who also brought their own methods of treatment.
Western medicine was disseminated by missionaries and merchants, travelers, and consular doctors. Before the era of translating Western medical textbooks into oriental languages, the extent of the transmission of Western medicine can be gauged, in some degree, by the recommendation by native physicians of Western treatments for the new Western diseases.In the early sixteenth century, whooping cough and syphilis were reported, for example, by the Persian Baha ad-Dawla. In one of his works he describes, in considerable detail, “the Armenian sore” that had spread from Europe to Constantinople and Arabia. Reportedly, syphilis had appeared in 1498 in Azerbaijan, and then in Iraq and Persia. Because of some symptomatic similarities with smallpox, it was known as “European pox” or “little fire.” It was also confused with anthrax or ignis persicus. Baha ad-Dawla observed the rash, sore throat, and neural involvement of the disease. He recommended purges, venesection, and appropriate foods and drugs, and he referred to European physicians, whom he did not mention by name. He recommended a salve known as the “European pox medicine,” which he believed could restore health if properly employed. Baha ad-Dawla did not say what the salve contained, but he mentioned a few lines later that mercury could be given in an electuary. Another of his recipes and one of the European physicians also contained mercury.
According to Leo Africanus, who wrote in the first half of the sixteenth century, syphilis was brought to North Africa by Jews driven out of Spain, and it spread rapidly among the Berber population.
In Fez “the first to be contaminated were regarded as lepers, driven from their homes, and obliged to live with the lepers.” The first mention of the appearance of syphilis in Egypt was made by Ibn Iyas in his contemporary chronicle of Egypt for the year 14978. Among the unhappy events of that year, an evil known as “the French pox had appeared among the people... the doctors were powerless in the face of this disease that had never appeared in Egypt before the beginning of this century; countless people died of it.”
Naturally, the indigenous physicians took cognizance of the new disease, and it is discussed in the medical textbook of Dawud ibn Umar al-Antaki, who wrote in the later sixteenth century and was perhaps the last great Arabic medical author in the Greek tradition. His textbook displays an intriguing mixture of hallowed Greco-Arabic medicine and the first indications of exposure to European learning, even in matters as small as the Western names for the months of the year.
More important, al-Antaki gives the earliest medical description of syphilis in Egypt in his chapter on carbuncles. He says that syphilis was popularly called “the blessed” in Egypt as a way of avoiding a mental association with the disease and contamination. As for treatment:
If one mixes mercury with frankincense, resin, wax, and oil and uses it as an ointment and if the patient is covered warmly for a week and eats proper and unsalted food, he recovers after suffering gangrene of the mouth, salivation, and tumefaction of the throat. If he becomes cold, he will feel pain in the joints. The ointment should be used three times a week. It is a well-known treatment in the hospital of Cairo. Sometimes one begins by applying the ointment to the extremities and the neck and only after a purge.
Interestingly, al-Antaki provides the entire mercury treatment for syphilis in his textbook as it was practiced in Europe until the eighteenth century.
The broader context in which al-Antaki worked is presented by Prosper Alpin in his description of medical practices in sixteenth-century Egypt.
His account, first published in 1591, is surely one of the earliest studies of non-European medicine, and Alpin himself well represents the means whereby Western medicine most effectively reached Egypt. He was an Italian physician-botanist; in 1580 he became physician to the Venetian consul in Cairo, where he spent three and a half years. Alpin did not confine himself to the closed European community in Cairo. He sought the widest possible contacts with Egyptians of all classes and religions. He treated their illnesses in collaboration with Egyptian doctors, and profited from the experience of these native physicians. Alpin watched them operate, observed their instruments, and talked at length with them since they shared the same Galenic tradition; he often criticized their knowledge of Galen but admired their empirical knowledge, which he believed went back to ancient Egyptian practice. He remarked particularly on the indigence and malnutrition of the poor and their medications. The habits of the ordinary people and the women’s remedies drew his attention, so that he returned to Italy with a large number of recipes for dishes, medicaments, clysters, and refreshments, including coffee. Alpin also observed the widespread and dangerous use Ofbloodletting as a panacea for all ills, as well as the common resort to baths for their therapeutic effects and the employment of numerous drugs and medications. These methods had been adopted, according to Alpin, for the new Western diseases, especially syphilis.In the long term, the appearance of these new diseases, in addition to periodic reappearances of plague, and the measures taken against these diseases by all the foreign European communities helped to diminish traditional Muslim opposition to the notion of contagion. Thus, in the seventeenth century, Evliya Chelebi, a renowned Turkish traveler, described the contagion of syphilis in Cairo quite matter-of-factly. The seventeenth century also witnessed clear evidence of the new age of European medicine, when Ibn Sallum, physician to the midcentury Ottoman sultan Mehmet IV, wrote his medical textbook. In this work Ibn Sallum not only described the new illnesses - for example, chlorosis, syphilis, scurvy, and Polish plait (plica polonica) - but an altogether new system of medicine, namely the “chemical medicine of Paracelsus.” Although the Paracelsian system was erroneous and Ibn Sallum’s influence may have been slight, the work clearly marks the advent of European medicine in the Middle East. With the introduction of Western-style medical schools in Cairo and Istanbul in the second quarter of the nineteenth century, the ascendancy of Western medicine was assured. All of this, however, was to the detriment of many traditional values and native forms of healing.
Michael VK Dols